Help : I messed up on Valentine's day!!?

so yesterday was valentines day and it wasn't terrible. My boyfriend showed up at my door really early with flowers, a teddy ber, my favorite breakfast, and a really nice card. I told him i would give him is gift later because it wasn't ready yet. This was a cover up. my gift just sucked compared to all he had done for me. So i went to the store, got some random stuff, and added it the the chessy personalized guitar picks i had already gotten him. When he opened it all he said he was happy, but it just seemed lame. After he left my house that night i immediately got him a jersey for his favorite sports team and tickets to a game. However, how do give this stuff to him without seeming like a total loser for not having a good gift that day? Do i say it was a makeup for the badness of the first gift or just how he forgets about the first one when he receives this one?